Trump’s Failure to Control the Central Bank Is a Huge Problem for His Trade Policy

Who’s in charge here?
Photo: Drew Angerer/Getty Images

Donald Trump hates trade deficits. He thinks countries that buy more than they sell are losers and those that sell more than they buy are winners.

At first blush, this idea seems stupid: China sends us goods, we send China little slips of paper in response, and we’re supposed to be the losers? On further consideration, the idea is … well, it’s still not quite correct, but maybe it’s a little less stupid than it seems. After all, persistent trade deficits can cause problems — this is what Ben Bernanke was talking about a few years ago when he warned about a “global savings glut” that had pushed the U.S. into unemployment-fueling trade deficits. But that’s situational. Sometimes trade deficits are bad; sometimes they’re desirable. It depends. Unemployment doesn’t appear to be elevated right now, so this doesn’t feel like the situation where we should be freaking out about how trade deficits are holding back the U.S. economy.

But for the president, trade-deficit analysis is not situational. Even though the economy is good (and he loves to talk about the economy being good), he still thinks trade deficits are bad. Unfortunately for him, some of the tools he hopes to use to fight them aren’t going to work.

Consider the trade war with China. Because the trade war is bad for the Chinese economy, Trump’s tariff announcements tend to cause China’s currency, the yuan, to weaken against the dollar. A weaker yuan (and, by implication, a stronger dollar) means Chinese products become cheaper for American buyers and American exports become more expensive for Chinese buyers. In addition to the currency effect, worse growth prospects also make Chinese consumers less inclined to consume either American exports or their own domestically produced goods — which tends to mean more Chinese goods will be available on the export market. It doesn’t help that Trump is pressuring China at a time when its economy is already softening for other reasons.

Nonetheless, Trump is demanding the Chinese target the trade deficit by agreeing to buy more American goods in aggregate. This isn’t normally how it works; normally, trade deficits arise based on the consumption actions of individual consumers and businesses, who buy imported cars and televisions or not as they see fit. But China is not a fully free-market economy, so I guess asking China to do this is less ridiculous than if we asked, say, France. There are a lot of state-controlled companies that the Chinese government can direct to buy more American soybeans and such. Unfortunately, it’s not clear that either Chinese importers or American exporters have the capacity to increase American exports to China as aggressively as the Trump administration would like, especially if Chinese buying capacity is further hampered by both weaker growth and a weaker currency.

If Trump wants to shrink the global trade deficit, what he should really want is a weaker dollar, which would make American exports cheaper for our trading partners and imports more expensive for American consumers. He could take a page from his favorite world leader, Angela Merkel: Germany has essentially followed a weak-currency policy over the past decade by lashing its economically weaker neighbors into a shared, low-inflation currency, leading to a German trade surplus and low employment. (Unfortunately, this policy also caused German wage growth to stagnate and exacerbated political and economic crises in southern Europe; but then, everything in public policy is trade-offs.)

The president seems to understand this; unlike most politicians, especially most Republican politicians, he’s been able to bring himself to say out loud that a strong dollar can be a bad thing. And he keeps urging the Federal Reserve to ease policy by cutting short-term interest rates and restarting its quantitative-easing activities to push down long-term-interest rates. Among other effects, such moves would tend to cause the dollar to weaken. And Trump tried to appoint some people to the Federal Reserve Board who would listen to his demands, but he failed to interest the Republican-controlled Senate in confirming them.

We have generally talked about Trump wanting political control over the Federal Reserve so he could get a short-term boost to the domestic economy, as low rates encourage businesses and individuals to borrow and invest. (I’ve also noted that Trump has sometimes been right on the merits, especially when he has made more modest asks, such as that the Fed should stop raising rates, which it did.) But another reason for Trump to have wanted a compliant Fed is to help implement his trade policy. His failure to get that control is a major threat to his very public goal of cutting the trade deficit, regardless of what he manages to talk China into in coming rounds of talks.

Trump’s Failure to Control the Fed Is a Huge Problem for Him

Promoted links by Taboola


Trump Pardons Billionaire Friend Conrad Black, Who Wrote Glowing Book About Him

By Matt Stieb

Black wrote that Trump isn’t racist, and was convicted of obstruction of justice after siphoning money from his newspaper. No wonder Trump likes him.

vision 2020

De Blasio Campaign Announcement Scooped by High School Journalist

By Matt Stieb

It’d make for an impressive college essay, but junior journalist Gabe Fleisher is already phenomenally overqualified.

abortion rights

Alabama’s Extreme Abortion Ban Has Been Signed into Law

By Amanda Arnold

But it will face legal challenges before it can take effect.

online extremism

online extremism

White House Refuses to Sign Accord to Fight Online Extremism After Christchurch

By Matt Stieb

The administration said that the “best tool to defeat terrorist speech is productive speech,” which is about as helpful as “thoughts and prayers.”

the top line

Trump’s Failure to Control the Fed Is a Huge Problem for His Trade Policy

By Josh Barro

Even though the economy is good, Trump still thinks trade deficits are bad. But the tools he hopes to use to fight them aren’t going to work.

vision 2020

Elizabeth Warren Unveils Plan for Cleaner, Greener War Machine

By Eric Levitz

Warren’s new climate plan focuses on greening the Pentagon. That’s a smart as a legislative tactic, but slightly off-brand as a campaign pledge.

this is coconuts

this is coconuts

Why Everyone Is Tweeting About Pee and Coconut Water

By Madison Malone Kircher

Yes, that social media manager is holding a jar of her own piss.

christian right

Georgia’s Christian Right Had a Bad Week

By Ed Kilgore

Georgia may pay a price for its anti-abortion “heartbeat bill,” and its insurance commissioner is in deep trouble for alleged corruption.

It’s rare that an exchange involving a comptroller is this interesting

.@ewarren grilling Comptroller of the Currency, Joseph Otting, on his treatment of Wells Fargo $wfc:

Otting: “No one has been more tougher on Wells Fargo than myself.”

Warren: “You mean, at the OCC? That’s a low bar.”

Otting: “I find that insulting.”

Warren: “Good.”




Extreme Abortion Bans Are Stepping All Over the GOP’s ‘Infanticide’ Message

By Ed Kilgore

It’s not easy to call the other party “extremists” when your own state legislatures are trying to ban abortion entirely.

open letter

Open Letter to Trump: Give Peace (and/or Trump Tower Tehran) a Chance

By Eric Levitz

There are better ways to deal with Iran than war, Mr. President. Trading sanctions relief for personal financial favors, for example.

Now the White House is arguing Congress can’t re-investigate the Mueller report – though they’re looking into some matters that fell outside the scope of the special counsel probe

White House Counsel Pat Cipollone’s letter to committee Chairman Jerrold Nadler (D-N.Y.) constitutes a sweeping rejection — not just of Nadler’s request for White House records, but of Congress’s standing to investigate Trump for possible obstruction of justice. In his letter, Cipollone repeated a claim the White House and Trump’s business have begun making: that Congress is not a law enforcement body and does not have a legitimate purpose to investigate the questions it is pursuing.

But Cipollone stopped short of asserting executive privilege. Instead, he told Nadler he would consider a narrowed request if the chairman spells out the legislative purpose and legal support for the information he is seeking.

“Congressional investigations are intended to obtain information to aid in evaluating potential legislation, not to harass political opponents or to pursue an unauthorized ‘do-over’ of exhaustive law enforcement investigations conducted by the Department of Justice,” Cipollone wrote.

Cipollone said the release of special counsel Robert S. Mueller III’s report now makes Congress’s questions moot. He stressed that probe was “exhaustive” — the product of 2,800 subpoenas, 500 executed search warrants and 500 witness interviews — and that the president supported the report’s full release “in the interest of transparency.”

“The appropriate course is for the Committee to discontinue the inquiry,” he wrote. “Unfortunately, it appears that you have already decided to press ahead with a duplicative investigation, including by issuing subpoenas, to replow the same ground the Special Counsel has already covered.”

donald trump

When Trump Gives Impulsive Orders, His Staff Often Ignores Him: Report

By Adam K. Raymond

The hope? That the child-in-chief will just forget.

the national interest

the national interest

How the Republican Party Built a Presidency Above the Law for Donald Trump

By Jonathan Chait

A legal doctrine of all power to the GOP, from Kenneth Starr to William Barr.



Influential Early Website YTMND Shuts Down

By Brian Feldman

The site, hosting elaborate GIFs and audio remixes, fell into disrepair years ago and is finally dead.

The rare Ted Cruz statement both sides may agree with

Sen. Ted Cruz this morning told the Trump administration’s nominee for head of the beleaguered Federal Aviation Administration that he needs to be outraged about how many people died in Boeing 737 MAX crashes in Ethiopia and Indonesia.

“Bureaucratic inertia is powerful,” Cruz (R-Texas) said at a Senate hearing on the the nomination of former Delta Air Lines executive Steve Dickson. “What I’m asking you to do, if confirmed, is: Be pissed off that 346 people died.”

Cruz said there had been a “serious breakdown in the certification process” and accused the FAA of “agency capture” by Boeing. He warned that easiest thing for Dickson to do as he assumes his new role is to do nothing.


Stephen A. Smith and the Lure of Losing

By Will Leitch

The Knicks’ strategy worked better than statistics predicted. So why does it feel like it failed?

Will anyone read the Fire and Fury follow up, now that Trump administration exposés have become their own genre?

Axios has learned that Michael Wolff — who enraged President Trump with his international bestseller “Fire and Fury,” about pandemonium in the first-year White House — will be out June 4 with a sequel, “Siege: Trump Under Fire.”

… The book, “about a presidency that is under fire from almost every side,” begins with Year 2 and ends with the delivery of the Mueller report. The publisher says: “‘Siege’ reveals an administration that is perpetually beleaguered by investigations and a president who is increasingly volatile, erratic, and exposed.”


How My Aversion to Twitter Became Cool

By Ed Kilgore

I kept resolving to keep up more with Twitter, until suddenly I found myself ahead of the curve.

voting rights

Voter Purges Show Why We Need a Constitutional Right to Vote

By Ed Kilgore

As one of the two major parties steadily moves toward open opposition to democratic principles, a stand for voting rights is essential.

Some good news for Republicans in North Carolina’s do-over election

Dan Bishop, a state senator and author of North Carolina’s controversial “bathroom bill,” beat back nine other Republican candidates Tuesday to clinch the GOP nomination for this year’s redo election in the state’s 9th Congressional District.

Bishop secured 48 percent of the vote, easily defeating Stony Rushing, the second-place candidate — and clearing the threshold needed to avoid a nasty runoff that would have further hurt the GOP’s chances of keeping a seat the party has held for decades.

With Bishop’s outright victory on Tuesday, he will face Democrat Dan McCready in the general election on Sept. 10. If no candidate had earned more than 30 percent of the vote, the party could have faced a runoff on that date — delaying the general election until November and allowing McCready to expand on his significant cash advantage.

Republicans have expressed anxiety about the do-over election, which was called after state officials found the previous Republican candidate’s campaign consultant likely engaged in illegal ballot harvesting in 2018. Dodging a runoff is sure to provide some relief for national Republicans, who were hoping to avoid an extended internal battle that would continue to boost McCready, who was unopposed in Tuesday’s primary.


TSA Is Sending Hundreds of Employees, Including Air Marshals, to the Border

By Adam K. Raymond

In internal emails, DHS acknowledged that the move comes with “some risk.”

For many people The Apprentice is more persuasive than numerous reports exposing Trump’s shoddy business skills

A majority, 54 percent, say they think Trump has been successful in business, the poll shows, while 36 percent say he has been unsuccessful. One in 10 voters say they have no opinion about his success.

Fully 85 percent of Republican voters say Trump has been successful, while only 10 percent say he’s been unsuccessful. Democratic voters see Trump’s business career differently: Three in 10, 30 percent, say he’s been successful, while 61 percent say he’s been unsuccessful. Among independents, 49 percent say Trump has been successful, and 34 percent say he’s been unsuccessful.

Scary stuff

An Ebola epidemic in a conflict-riven region of Democratic Republic of Congo is out of control and could become as serious as the outbreak that devastated three countries in west Africa between 2013 and 2016, experts and aid chiefs have warned.

New cases over the past month have increased at the fastest rate since the outbreak began last year, as aid agencies struggle to enact a public health response in areas that have suffered decades of neglect and conflict, with incredibly fragile health systems and regular outbreaks of deadly violence involving armed groups.

If only there were some large group of people hoping to come to the U.S. and join our labor force

The number of babies born in the U.S. in 2018 fell to the lowest level in 32 years, according to a government report released Wednesday.

The numbers are part of a decadeslong trend toward fewer and fewer babies being born each year — which means we’re getting further away from the possibility of having enough children to replace ourselves, according to the report from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

… There are some serious implications that could result from the declining birth rates, Rowe said. “Long term it means we’re going to have an increasing proportion of older people,” he added. “All the projections about what percent of the population will be elderly in 5, 10, 20 years from now were made with the assumption that the birth rate would be stable.”

The lowered birthrate will “have a significant impact on the labor force,” Rowe said.

vision 2020

Democrats: Trump’s GOP Is a Threat to Democracy – So We Better Play Nice

By Eric Levitz

Pelosi and Biden argue that the GOP is breaking our democracy – and therefore, Democrats must not impeach Trump or give up on bipartisanship.

The idea of officials obeying the Hatch Act seems increasingly quaint

A Trump appointee displayed a “Make America Great Again” hat at her Housing and Urban Development office.

A top official at the Office of Management and Budget used his official Twitter account to promote President Donald Trump’s campaign slogan.

And White House Counselor Kellyanne Conway delivered a scathing and unprompted attack on Trump’s potential opponent, Joe Biden, during a TV interview.

Those three instances — all in the last few months — are just a few of the growing number of complaints since Trump took office that federal employees are using their platform to campaign for the president or his allies, a violation of the Hatch Act. In Trump’s first year on the job, formal complaints to the government office that oversees compliance with the 80-year-old law jumped nearly 30 percent.

new york magazine

new york magazine

How Weegee’s Biographer Figured Out the Location of This Photo From 1937

By Aude White

New York magazine discovered a trove of new photos by legendary crime-scene photographer Weegee. Here’s how his biographer pinned down one image.

Read More


Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: