Entertaining WE



Why Is Kamala Harris Struggling With Black Voters So Much?

Why Is Kamala Harris Struggling With Black Voters So Much?

Can she figure it all out?
Photo: Justin Sullivan/Getty Images

Ben: As Ed detailed in a post yesterday, Kamala Harris still isn’t gaining much traction among black voters in the Democratic primary, coming in at below 10 percent in two recent national polls. Joe Biden continues to dominate among this group, but Elizabeth Warren and Bernie Sanders have recently both polled ahead of Harris, too. Harris’s showing stands in contrast to Barack Obama, who by this this point in 2007 was already posting impressive numbers in South Carolina, among other places, on his way to a decisive victory. Why do you think Harris is having so much trouble?

Ed: I’d offer three quick reasons: (1) History has already been made with Obama, so there’s less perceived need for African-Americans to unite behind a black candidate; (2) Obama was a world-historical figure by the time he announced in 2007; Harris is mostly known as a cleverly tactical pol; and (3) the Electability Terror of 2020.

Zak: I think Ed’s No. 3 is my best guess. Black voters want to beat Trump, and Biden has this unifying credential, in Obama’s vice presidency, that is interpreted as the closest option we’ve got to a candidate with broad enough appeal.

Ed: 2008 was thought of as an auspicious Democratic year at the time. W. was heading for the exits as a very unpopular president.  Democrats had won by a landslide in 2006. The financial collapse just made things harder for Republicans. So while there were some electability fears early on about Obama, they faded pretty fast.

Zak: People know what they’re getting with Biden, and they seem to be convinced that what they’re getting works. To the extent that Harris is even comparably well known, the historic nature of her campaign seems less imperative with four more years of Trump looming. And to the extent that her being more moderate than Warren or Sanders is meant to broaden her appeal, Biden seems like the safest of the moderate options. Folks who want a dyed-in-the-wool progressive are going to gravitate toward Sanders or Warren.

Ed: Yeah, as I noted, Harris isn’t just losing black voters to Biden; Warren and Sanders are doing pretty well there as well.

Ben: Do you think voter fear that a woman can’t get elected — which of course has been magnified after 2016 — plays a big role in all this?

Ed: Hard to say. Doesn’t seem to be hurting Elizabeth Warren much.

Zak: My sense is that’s secondary to how firmly people seem convinced that Biden is their best bet for beating Trump. Hillary got the nomination and won the popular vote in 2016, and Warren is polling well. If Biden and his credentials were off the table, my guess is that Harris would be right up there. In other words, I don’t think the majority of black voters think there’s anything particularly wrong or unelectable about Harris. She’s just running against Biden in the Trump era. And as we’ve seen with the debates and subsequent polling, it’s hard to disabuse folks of the notion that Biden is a good bet, no matter how much he does to challenge that notion.

Ed: The fact that Harris’s maximum moment of fame in this campaign so far was a direct challenge to Biden on his commitment to racial justice is fascinating. For a moment, it looked like it might simultaneously hurt Biden among black voters and elevate Harris to a point close to where Obama was in 2007. But then it faded.

Ben: It’s true that black voters may not think there’s anything particularly unelectable about Harris. But surely she’s played some role in her own troubles. Besides that one viral debate moment, which, as Ed said, briefly sent her into the stratosphere, she has been quite shaky on policy (her answers on health care are all over the place) and vision (seems to be synthesis of everyone else’s). If she had been more consistent, isn’t it plausible that she’d be in more direction competition with Biden by now?

Ed: Maybe, though Cory Booker has been more consistent and has some authentic appeal to African-Americans, and he’s in much worse shape than Harris.

Ben: Yeah, though I never thought he had much of a shot in the first place.

Zak: I think voters’ understanding of electoral viability is fairly set here. Biden’s resilience is a testament to that. I’m becoming less convinced with time that there’s much any candidate in that area between the perceived “safeness” of Biden and the progressive vision and energy of Warren and Sanders can do to make dramatic and lasting inroads against either.

The best thing Harris had going for her was being inspiring and historic. This just doesn’t seem to be an election where majorities of voters, black voters included, are especially invested in being inspired or making history.

Ed: According to some sources, Harris is now committed to making a splash in Iowa, apparently in the belief that that’s how Obama achieved his breakthrough moment with black voters in South Carolina. As I explained in my own post, Obama was doing very well among black voters in South Carolina and elsewhere before winning Iowa (though it did give him a boost into the front-runner’s role). And I think Harris has a really tough row to hoe in Iowa. Not because of her race or ideology, but because she’s really behind the curve there.

Ben: In your view, what is the most plausible way out of the spot Harris finds herself in today?

Zak: It would help to stake out a consistent political identity. Your observation earlier about how she’s hurting herself by being shaky and derivative on policy and overall vision was fair, I think.

Ed: Three things: (1) She has to play error-free baseball, from now on; no more bad or meh debate performances; (2) she needs to begin to inspire people on some issue or set of issues — she’s just way too tactical; and (3) Biden has to really screw up.

Number three is obviously beyond her control.

Ben: Maybe gaffe number 743 will do it.

Ed: There does always seem to be one just over the next hill, doesn’t there?

Why Is Kamala Harris Struggling With Black Voters So Much?

Promoted links by Taboola

gun reform

Trump Is ‘Convinced’ McConnell Will Move on Gun Reform. His Aides Says He Won’t.

By Matt Stieb

Despite GOP senators’ private opposition to background checks, Trump thinks that Republicans are ready to act after August’s mass shootings.

stacey abrams

Abrams Not Running for President but Will Fight Voter Suppression Nationally

By Ed Kilgore

She is keeping her veep options open and may still run for governor of Georgia in 2022.

sent from my ifridge

sent from my ifridge

We Talked to the Teen Who Tweeted From Her Fridge After Her Mom Took Her Phone

By Brian Feldman

Desperate times called for desperate measures for one dedicated Ariana Grande fan.

kamala harris

Why Is Kamala Harris Struggling With Black Voters So Much?

By Zak Cheney-Rice, Benjamin Hart, and Ed Kilgore

Intelligencer staffers discuss the Democratic contender’s weakness among a key primary demographic.

Stacey Abrams will focus on voting rights in 2020, won’t run for president

Stacey Abrams, the Georgia politician who captured national attention during her unsuccessful run for governor in 2018, has decided not to run for president after publicly contemplating a bid for months, according to people familiar with her thinking.

Ms. Abrams will instead put her efforts into preventing voter suppression, including working with state parties in battleground states to more closely monitor voter protection ahead of next year’s general election.

The move comes after civil rights groups raised questions about voter suppression and election rigging in Ms. Abrams’ 2018 race against Brian Kemp, a Republican who was Georgia’s secretary of state.

trade war

Trump Just Admitted That Tariffs Hurt Consumers

By Eric Levitz

After insisting that China “paid” his tariffs, Trump delayed a new round of duties to spare “U.S. customers” during “the Christmas season.”

the n-word

Unless It’s the N-Word, It’s Probably Not ‘Like the N-Word’

By Zak Cheney-Rice

Chris Cuomo apologized for equating the term ‘Fredo’ with black people being called the ‘N-word.’ But he was echoing a broader trend.

This checks out

Trump says that when he was a little boy, like four years old, he loved trucks, and even though he’s now president, he still loves trucks, nothing has changed, he loves trucks.


jeffrey epstein

Everything We Know About Jeffrey Epstein’s Death

By Chas Danner, Margaret Hartmann, and Matt Stieb

FBI agents raided Epstein’s home in the Virgin Islands on Monday.

This may just be the start

WASHINGTON (AP) — Justice Department says 2 guards assigned to watch Jeffrey Epstein placed on leave; warden is temporarily reassigned.


Some lighthearted stuff from the president

Trump tells the workers, in this official speech allegedly about energy, that they can drive the media “totally crazy” if they “go to hashtag third term, hashtag fourth term,” suggesting he’ll stay in office longer than two terms.


This sure would have been a sweet deal for LaPierre

A top National Rifle Association executive signed a document agreeing that the gun-rights organization would be 99% owner of a company formed to buy a $6 million Dallas mansion for NRA CEO Wayne LaPierre, according to a copy of the document reviewed by The Wall Street Journal.

The document also shows the NRA agreed to contribute $6.5 million to the company formed to buy the property, raising yet more questions about the NRA’s previous statements that none of the gun-rights group’s money was to be used to purchase the house for Mr. LaPierre.

The house-purchase deal never happened, but conflicting explanations from the NRA and its former ad agency for the aborted transaction have renewed the focus on Mr. LaPierre’s financial dealings with the agency, Ackerman McQueen Inc.

vision 2020

Democratic 2020 Field May Be Sliced in Half by Debate Cut

By Ed Kilgore

Just enough candidates may qualify for the third round in Houston to force two nights of debates, but soon the field should seriously be winnowed.

2020 democratic primaries

2020 democratic primaries

Tom Steyer Bought Himself a ‘Grassroots Campaign’ for $10 Million

By Eric Levitz

The billionaire candidate insists that he is the Democrats’ only credible messenger on preventing big money from distorting our politics.

A new Epstein-related mystery

The New York City Fire Department looked into whether a first responder posted about Jeffrey Epstein’s death on a notorious internet message board prior to officials announcing it to the public, BuzzFeed News has learned.

Shortly after telling BuzzFeed News the post was “under review,” an FDNY spokesperson said authorities “determined this alleged information did not come from the Fire Department.” The spokesperson did not elaborate on how that determination was made.

Less than 40 minutes before ABC News first reported Epstein’s death on Twitter, someone posted still-unverified details on 4chan, the anonymous message board popular with far-right trolls and white nationalists.


Ken Cuccinelli Suggests MAGA-Friendly Edits to Statue of Liberty Inscription

By Adam K. Raymond

“Give me your tired and your poor who can stand on their own two feet.”

deflation fetish

deflation fetish

A Brief Chat With Jan Hakon Erichsen, the Twitter Balloon Guy

By Brian Feldman

Knives, balloons, and plywood make a surreal and absurd viral video.

Oh, ok

Trump said his retweet of the Clinton-Epstein conspiracy theory was “fine” because it was from a man with 500,000 followers who is “very respected.”


Classic Trump, solving a problem he caused

AP: Stocks soar after US delays plans for some China tariffs


chris cuomo

Trump’s Chris Cuomo Jab Appears to Make Light of ‘Red Flag’ Laws

By Benjamin Hart

Maybe America’s troll-in-chief needs a mandatory waiting period for his jokes.

The U.S. blinks on the trade war, at least for now

NEW: U.S. announces tariff set to be slapped on $300 billion of Chinese imports will be delayed until later this year for certain products, including cell phones, laptops, some toys and select clothing items.


the media

Chris Cuomo Rages at ‘F*cking Punk’ Who Called Him ‘Fredo’

By Adam K. Raymond

Video shows the CNN anchor threatening to throw a man down a set of stairs for the unkind comparison to the idiot brother from The Godfather.

America is crying out for more Tom Steyer

I’m thrilled to announce that today we’ve reached the required 130,000 individual donors to appear in September’s debate. Just one more qualifying poll stands between us and that stage!

Thanks to all who’ve contributed even $1 to this movement. We can’t do this without you.


The rare candidate who could one-up Trump on the craziness

Curt Schilling, a great pitcher and patriot, is considering a run for Congress in Arizona. Terrific! @foxandfriends


vision 2020

Kamala Harris Is Trying to Run Obama’s ’08 Playbook. She Has Ground to Make Up.

By Ed Kilgore

The Californian has modeled her campaign on the 44th president’s. But she’s currently not doing well among black voters or in South Carolina.

Flights were canceled in Hong Kong due to another day of airport protests

Anti-government protesters brought chaos to Hong Kong’s airport for a second consecutive day Tuesday, forcing airlines to suspend check-in for departing flights, as demonstrators extended their standoff with authorities who have been unable to quell months of dissent.

After mass cancellations the previous evening, flights had been gradually returning to normal throughout Tuesday, even as thousands of black-clad demonstrators returned to occupy the terminal with placards denouncing police brutality and calling for freedom for Hong Kong.

But by late afternoon, with protesters using luggage carts as makeshift barricades and blocking passengers from reaching the departure gates, causing long lines, airport authorities said they were suspending check-in at both terminals.

Ivanka would like us to know she’s “quietly” working on gun legislation

Ivanka Trump has quietly been making calls to members of Congress in the days following the deadly mass shootings in Dayton and El Paso to gauge where they stand on pending gun legislation, sources familiar with her conversations told Axios.

Behind the scenes: Members she has privately spoken to include Sen. Joe Manchin (D-W.Va.), who she called last Wednesday while he was vacationing in Hawaii to get an update on the bipartisan background checks bill he has proposed with Sen. Pat Toomey (R-Penn.).

The measure, which was initially introduced in 2013 in the wake of the Sandy Hook shooting, would expand background checks to nearly all commercial firearm sales.

“She called Manchin and said she was trying to get a sense of what bills are out there. She had him explain how they drafted the bill, where it stands and what changes needed to be made in order for it to pass,” a Manchin aide told Axios. The two had “a good talk,” but Ivanka didn’t make it clear one way or the other what the White House’s position is, the aide added.

The call followed President Trump’s own conversations with Manchin last Monday and Tuesday, first reported by the Washington Post, in which he told the senator that he wanted legislation before the Senate returns from recess in September.

jeffrey epstein

New York Times Columnist: Epstein Said He Had Dirt on Powerful Acquaintances

By Matt Stieb

According to James B. Stewart, Epstein claimed to have damaging info on rich pals, and said criminalizing sex with teens was a “cultural aberration.”

jeffrey epstein

The Legal Aftermath of Jeffrey Epstein’s Death: What Happens Next

By Matt Stieb

Prosecutors intend to pursue his co-conspirators, as lawyers representing his alleged victims look to dismantle his fortune.

vision 2020

Trump’s State-by-State Approval Ratings Should Scare the MAGA Out of Him

By Ed Kilgore

Translating Trump’s standing in the 50 states to the 2020 electoral college vote currently shows the incumbent getting trounced.

Read More


Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: