By Barring Omar and Tlaib, Netanyahu Did BDS a Huge Favor

Bibi played himself.
Photo: Saul Loeb/AFP/Getty Images

In deference to the wishes of the United States government, Israel has barred two members of the U.S. Congress from entering its borders. Or at least that’s how Thursday’s bizarre developments in American-Israeli relations appear to have played out.

Democratic congresswomen Ilhan Omar and Rashida Tlaib had been poised to visit Jerusalem, Bethlehem, Ramallah, and Hebron as part of a trip ostensibly aimed at raising global awareness of Israel’s occupation of the West Bank and strengthening American progressives’ ties to Palestinian civil society. Omar and Tlaib are both supporters of the Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions movement, also known as BDS, which calls on the global community to cut off economic ties with Israel until it ends its occupation of the West Bank and blockade of Gaza. Many within the movement also favor a “one-state solution” to the Israel-Palestine conflict, which would unify the region under a single, binational government.

Israel regards BDS as an anti-Semitic movement and a threat to its existence, and passed a law in 2017 forbidding the campaign’s adherents from entering the country. Meanwhile, the Israeli government’s allies in the U.S. have pushed (unconstitutional) laws that would make it a crime for Americans to exercise their freedom of expression by refusing to do business with Israeli firms for political reasons. Nevertheless, as of last month, Israel’s ambassador to the U.S. Ron Dermer insisted that the Jewish State would make an exception for Omar and Tlaib “out of respect for the U.S. Congress and the great alliance between Israel and America.” The American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC) — a stalwart ally of the Israeli government on Capitol Hill, and vehement critic of Omar and Tlaib — shared this position.

And it isn’t hard to see why. Two pro-BDS congresswomen conducting a series of press events in the Palestinian territories might generate some displeasing headlines for Benjamin Netanyahu’s government. But it would hardly qualify as a major news headline. By contrast, one of America’s closest allies blocking two U.S. officials from stepping foot on its soil — one of whom has a grandmother in the West Bank — is the stuff that cable-news top stories are made of. And Israel has no interest in putting a spotlight on its illiberal laws, or Omar and Tlaib’s advocacy for BDS. Both congresswomen currently enjoy more widespread popularity and goodwill among American progressives than the movement to boycott Israel does. Thus, anything that increases awareness of their views on Israel — let alone makes them appear more sympathetic — is a huge gift to BDS’s recruitment efforts.

But if Israel has no interest in turning Omar and Tlaib’s support for BDS into prime-time cable-news fodder, Donald Trump does. The American president has made it abundantly clear that he sees all publicity for “the squad” of left-wing nonwhite congresswomen as good publicity for the Republican Party. Omar and Tlaib may be popular with progressive activists, but they are not necessarily the Democrats’ ideal messengers to the white, culturally conservative Rust Belt swing voters who wield such disproportionate influence in the Electoral College. For this reason, Trump and Fox News have worked tirelessly to make “the squad” the face of the Democratic Party (even when doing so involves making white nationalism the face of the GOP).

One hesitates to assign any strategic logic or forethought to the contents of Donald Trump’s Twitter feed. But it seems likely that the president knew what signals he was boosting Thursday when he tweeted, “It would show great weakness if Israel allowed Rep. Omar and Rep.Tlaib to visit. They hate Israel & all Jewish people, & there is nothing that can be said or done to change their minds. Minnesota and Michigan will have a hard time putting them back in office. They are a disgrace!” Shortly thereafter, the Israeli government confirmed that it would not allow Omar and Tlaib to visit.

Officially, the Trump administration’s lobbying had no influence on this decision. On Thursday afternoon, Netanyahu’s office said in a series of tweets that it chose to bar the congresswomen after an examination of their itinerary “revealed that they planned a visit whose sole objective is to strengthen the boycott against us and deny Israel’s legitimacy.” This account is hard to believe, given that the government received said itinerary days ago, and only blocked the visit after Trump’s public intervention. But if Israel’s official reasoning is genuine, then its government is run by fools.

For hours on Thursday, the number-one trending topic on U.S. Twitter was Israel; the most prominent hashtag, “#BoycottIsrael.” This is extraordinary. As a digital journalist who has written on Israel-Palestine from time to time over the past five years, I can tell you that coverage of the conflict typically attracts relatively limited reader interest in this country. It takes a strong, U.S.-centric news hook to compel American news consumers to pay events overseas much mind. Together, Trump and Netanyahu provided BDS supporters a hook so juicy, the latter’s preferred topic has become a major social-media conversation.

That is no small win for both the BDS movement and supporters of Palestinian rights more broadly. To the extent that there is a path for allies of Palestinian liberation to end America’s complicity with the Israeli occupation, it involves turning reflexive support for the Jewish State into a partisan issue — and turning support for a more adversarial posture toward the Israeli government into an article of progressive faith. Netanyahu has been aiding that project for a while now, by broadcasting his contempt for Barack Obama and sympathy for the Republican Party. And the prime minister’s allies in the Knesset have made the task of radicalizing American liberals on Israel easier by pushing to replace de facto apartheid rule in the West Bank with the de jure variety. None of this has been enough for mainstream Democrats to embrace the idea of making U.S. aid to Israel contingent on an end to settlement expansion, let alone to persuade the average Democrat to boycott Israel’s products. But it has opened up space for Bernie Sanders to champion the former. And there are some signs that public opinion in blue America is (very) slowly turning more hostile to the Israeli government. One 2014 poll found half of all Democrats under 30 voicing support for punishing Israeli settlement expansion with economic sanctions. The vast majority of that age bracket also preferred the United States to remain neutral in the Israel-Palestine conflict; among those who wanted America to pick a side, most wished for their government to support the Palestinians, a stance shared by no other age group in either party.

Some part of this shift can be attributed to demographics. Young Democrats are less white than their co-partisans, and Hispanics and African-Americans evince more sympathy for the Palestinian plight than the general population. In fact, 44 percent of Hispanic-Americans — of all ages and political parties — supported sanctioning Israel over its settlement activity in 2014.

It’s hard to imagine a better way of hardening young, nonwhite Democrats’ skepticism toward Israel than prohibiting two of America’s most prominent nonwhite Democratic politicians from visiting the country. Which is to say: On Thursday, Trump and Bibi did more to aid the BDS movement (and less radical allies of the Palestinian cause) than Omar and Tlaib’s trip ever could.

By Barring Omar and Tlaib, Netanyahu Did BDS a Huge Favor

Promoted links by Taboola

vision 2020

It’s Filibuster Reform–Or Bust–For Democrats in the Near Future

By Ed Kilgore

The odds of Democrats being able to get anything done even if they win in 2020 are low without the filibuster reform that some senators still resist.


Report: Trump, Who Is the President, Wants to Buy Greenland

By Benjamin Hart

A child’s vision of power.

for fc’s sake

Amazon’s ‘Ambassador’ Program Is Hilariously Misconceived

By Brian Feldman

The program is meant to be damage control, but it feels like a hostage situation.


California Is Headed Toward a Titanic Battle Over Raising Property Taxes

By Ed Kilgore

Billions of dollars in tax revenue is at stake in the first major effort to modify California’s Prop 13, which limits property taxes.


By Barring Omar and Tlaib, Netanyahu Did BDS a Huge Favor

By Eric Levitz

Calling attention to Israel’s illiberalism and the congresswomen’s advocacy for Palestinian rights will increase support for BDS.

A reminder that the president is a great guy

The mayor of El Paso said after he corrected President Trump about crime statistics in his city, the president called him a “RINO,” a pejorative nickname that means “Republican in Name Only.”

Mayor Dee Margo told PBS’s “Frontline” in an interview published Wednesday that Trump made those comments in a private conversation they had while the president was in El Paso last week to pay respects after a mass shooting that killed 22 people and injured dozens more.

“He said, ‘You’re a RINO,’ and I said, ‘No sir, I’m not a RINO, I simply corrected the misinformation you were given by our attorney general, and that’s all I did’,” Margo recounted.

vision 2020

Trump’s Misogynistic Triumph: Democrats Are Afraid to Nominate a Woman

By Ed Kilgore

Democrats’ assumption that swing voters share Trump’s misogyny has led them to sexist thinking about “electability.”


Israel Bars Ilhan Omar and Rashida Tlaib From Visiting

By Benjamin Hart

President Trump is enthusiastically onboard with this terrible decision.

vision 2020

John Hickenlooper Ends Presidential Bid, to Give ‘Serious Thought’ to Senate Run

By Matt Stieb and Adam K. Raymond

In a video announcing the end of his candidacy, the former Colorado governor said he’ll give “serious thought” to a Senate run.


Watch Ben Shapiro (Accidentally) Destroy the Myth of Meritocracy

By Eric Levitz

America’s foremost conservative intellectual argues that our economy pays workers what they deserve, thereby proving that it pays him far too much.

Hickenlooper out

This morning, I’m announcing that I’m no longer running for President. While this campaign didn’t have the outcome we were hoping for, every moment has been worthwhile & I’m thankful to everyone who supported this campaign and our entire team.


Trump’s capitalization style is at late 16th century levels now

The United States is now, by far, the Biggest, Strongest and Most Powerful Economy in the World, it is not even close! As others falter, we will only get stronger. Consumers are in the best shape ever, plenty of cash. Business Optimism is at an All Time High!


Even AIPAC thinks Omar and Tlaib should be allowed into Israel

We disagree with Reps. Omar and Tlaib’s support for the anti-Israel and anti-peace BDS movement, along with Rep. Tlaib’s calls for a one-state solution. We also believe every member of Congress should be able to visit and experience our democratic ally Israel firsthand.


It wasn’t your imagination. July was historically hot

Much of the planet sweltered in unprecedented heat in July, as temperatures soared to new heights in the hottest month ever recorded. The record warmth also shrank Arctic and Antarctic sea ice to historic lows.

The average global temperature in July was 1.71 degrees F above the 20th-century average of 60.4 degrees, making it the hottest July in the 140-year record, according to scientists at NOAA’s National Centers for Environmental Information. The previous hottest month on record was July 2016. 

Beto resets, again

Beto O’Rourke introduced himself to the country as a changed candidate on Thursday, with his presidential campaign recast as a moral crusade against President Trump in the aftermath of a mass shooting in El Paso, his hometown.

Mr. O’Rourke, who represented the city in Congress until the start of this year, said he would abandon the relatively traditional approach he has so far taken — with limited success — and largely detach his travel from a primary calendar that tethers most candidates to a handful of early-voting states like Iowa and New Hampshire.

Instead, Mr. O’Rourke said he would now plan his political activities around confronting Mr. Trump in direct and personal terms, and highlighting what Mr. O’Rourke views as the injustices of Mr. Trump’s administration. He intends to seek out immigrant-rich towns to campaign in, and to make gun control a central issue.


Truck Rams Crowd of ICE Protesters Outside Rhode Island Prison

By Adam K. Raymond

The incident, which sent five people to the hospital, was caught on video.

Trump back in attack dog mode against Ilhan Omar, Rashida Tlaib

It would show great weakness if Israel allowed Rep. Omar and Rep.Tlaib to visit. They hate Israel & all Jewish people, & there is nothing that can be said or done to change their minds. Minnesota and Michigan will have a hard time putting them back in office. They are a disgrace!


vision 2020

Primary Voters Are Focused on Beating Trump, So the Candidates Are, Too

By Ed Kilgore

Yes, Democratic presidential candidates are talking a lot about Trump. But that’s mostly because they are auditioning to take him down.

Until recently, Walmart sold semi-automatic rifles. Now, its CEO supports a national ban.

Walmart CEO Doug McMillon on guns: “We believe the reauthorization of the Assault Weapons ban should be debated to determine its effectiveness in keeping weapons made for war out of the hands of mass murderers.”



America’s Most Socialist Generation Is Also Its Most Misanthropic

By Eric Levitz

Young adults are exceptionally distrustful of the state (and each other) — and yet, exceptionally supportive of socialism and redistribution.

jeffrey epstein

What We Know About Jeffrey Epstein’s Autopsy

By Adam K. Raymond

Epstein reportedly suffered breaks in the front of his neck that are consistent with hanging but more common in cases of homicidal strangulation.

The president has plenty of down time and no late nights, so this makes sense

Allies to Joe Biden have been floating the idea of altering the former vice president’s schedule in an effort to reduce the gaffes he has made in recent days.

The allies, growing increasingly nervous about Biden’s verbal flubs, have said it’s an approach that’s been suggested to campaign officials on the heels of the former vice president’s stumbles.

Biden has a tendency to make the blunders late in the day, his allies say, particularly after a long swing on the road, like he had last week in Iowa. They say something needs to be done to give the candidate more down time as the campaign intensifies in the fall.

“He needs to be a strong force on the campaign trail but he also has to pace himself,” said one ally who has talked to members of the campaign team and others in the broader Biden world about how to move forward.

Today Trump will venture into the half of the country he usually ignores

President Trump will venture on Thursday into New Hampshire, a state that might represent the best opportunity for him to take back territory won by Democrat Hillary Clinton in the 2016 presidential race.

But to take New Hampshire, Trump will need to expand beyond his core base of supporters and win over the sort of establishment Republicans who have resisted his charms not only in the Granite State but around the country.

The trip is a rare foray to a bluish state by Trump, who hasn’t held a rally in a state Clinton won since October, when he appeared with three Republican incumbents in southern Illinois in the run-up to the midterm elections.

The police commissioner said it’s “nothing short of a miracle” that none of the officers were killed

A gunman who opened fire on police Wednesday as they were serving a drug warrant in Philadelphia, wounding six officers and triggering a standoff that extended into the night, is in police custody, authorities said.

Philadelphia police Sgt. Eric Gripp said early Thursday morning that the man was taken into custody after an hourslong standoff with police.

The shooting began around 4:30 p.m. as officers went to a home in a north Philadelphia neighborhood of brick and stone rowhomes to serve a narcotics warrant in an operation “that went awry almost immediately,” Philadelphia Police Commissioner Richard Ross said.

Many officers “had to escape through windows and doors to get (away) from a barrage of bullets,” Ross said.

The six officers who were struck by gunfire have been released from hospitals, Gripp said.

jeffrey epstein

jeffrey epstein

Everything We Know About Jeffrey Epstein’s Death

By Chas Danner, Margaret Hartmann, and Matt Stieb

On Wednesday one of Epstein’s accusers filed a lawsuit against his estate, Ghislaine Maxwell, and several household staffers.

jeffrey epstein

Jeffrey Epstein Owned a Painting of Bill Clinton in a Blue Dress: Report

By Matt Stieb

According to a source in law enforcement, the oil painting was hanging in Epstein’s Manhattan mansion “as soon as you walked in.”

just asking questions

just asking questions

Jeffrey Epstein’s Bodyguard on His Former Boss’s Lifestyle, Cruelty, and Suicide

By M.L. Nestel

Former UFC fighter Igor Zinoviev went everywhere with Epstein. In his first interview, he says he thinks Epstein had help ending his life.

the top line

Here’s What the ‘CRAZY INVERTED YIELD CURVE’ Means for You

By Josh Barro

An unusual configuration of bond yields is not proof that we’re going into a recession. But there’s a reason the stock market is spooked.


Give Me Your Tired, Your Poor, Your Huddled Masses*

By Zak Cheney-Rice

Ken Cuccinelli has a vision for immigration that privileges people who’ll enrich America. But for him and Trump, that has always meant white people.

Read More


Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: