Entertaining WE



A Non-Racist Conservative Movement Would Kill the Republican Party

A Non-Racist Conservative Movement Would Kill the Republican Party

Scene from a Trump rally, 2019.

Scene from a Trump rally, 2019.
Photo: Spencer Platt/Getty Images

The Republican Party controls the White House, the United States Senate, and the majority of governorships and state legislatures. Champions for the political project of conservatism — specifically, the people focused on shaping law and policy and winning elections for the GOP — control the Supreme Court and the most watched network on cable television, Fox News. From this perch, they’ve pursued an agenda dedicated, in large part, to demonizing immigrants from Central America, the Caribbean, Africa, and the Middle East, while extolling the virtues of those from Europe; curtailing voting rights and seeking to reduce political representation for black and Hispanic people, for the express purpose of winning elections; and criminalizing abortion and reducing affordable health-care options in states where maternal and infant mortality rates are worse than in many less developed economies, especially for black women and children.

They’ve advanced their cause by uniting behind a president, Donald Trump, who spouts racism and xenophobia as a matter of routine, but whose approval ratings among Republican voters nevertheless consistently top 80 percent. Whenever they’re polled on the subject, large shares of these voters express bigoted views — 40 percent think black people are “lazier” than whites, nearly half think black people are more “criminal” and “violent,” and close to 60 percent hold unfavorable opinions about Islam. This is to be expected: Racism has been fundamental to American conservatism, and the GOP in particular, since the mid-20th century realignment of the parties — even as its purportedly defining tenets have proven to be negotiable, from small government to antagonism toward autocrats to reduced deficit spending. None of this precludes the existence of non-racist conservatives, to be sure. It just makes them some of the least influential people in their movement, and renders their claims to broader relevance akin to shouting into a void.

But the void got slightly louder on Wednesday. Two op-eds by conservative columnists were published with essentially the same theme: American conservatism has a racism problem, and conservatives who care must build a movement that is unwelcoming to racists. The first, by Ross Douthat at the New York Times, uses this argument to qualify the real purpose of his piece, which is to lambast a handful of liberal commentators for falsely accusing four individual conservatives of being racists. The second piece, by Timothy P. Carney at the Washington Examiner, is more soul-searching. It documents his dismay at realizing the conservative movement has been an alarmingly hospitable home for racists; his recognition that racial disparities in America stem from racism; and his belief that “the right thing” to do for conservatives is to scare away racists and make the best interests of nonwhite people central to their politics. Both cite Hannah Gais’s Splinter exposé about white nationalism run amok at conservative institutions, especially the Daily Caller, as evidence that the problem has gotten out of hand. And both call for inward-facing solutions: Douthat and Carney both insist that liberals will invent racism where it doesn’t exist and call conservatives racist no matter what; conservatives therefore need to fight racism on their own terms, for and among one another, without worrying about what the other side says.

This casting of liberalism hinges on the belief that liberal accusations of racism are as cynical as conservative denial of them. It’s an odd way of dismissing the very people who sounded the alarm about where the GOP was headed when much of the conservative intelligentsia was busy using op-ed pages and cable-news appearances to launder its descent. It’s a tall order to thank one’s political opponents for their honest assessment of you, to be fair. But the bigger problem for Douthat and Carney is that there’s little evidence that a market for the brand of conservatism they’re proposing exists — at least not in significant enough numbers to win elections and influence policy. Even assuming theirs is purely a moral imperative — one concerned more with doing the right thing than with victory — both writers are strikingly focused on minutiae: Their personal discomfort, the presence at once-respected conservative think tanks and online publications of individual white nationalists, and their dogged insistence that these realities don’t actually represent conservatives, many of whom, they insist, aren’t actually racist.

Change has to begin somewhere, of course, and eradicating toxic elements from one’s political movement is laudable, especially when you’re fighting uphill against the majority. But the flagrant racism conveyed in Trump’s speeches and Jonah Bennett’s emails at the Daily Caller is less intractable than a movementwide mobilization behind a racist agenda. That Republicans have built a reliable coalition of racists and purported non-racists by pairing tax cuts and abortion restrictions with the subordination of black civil rights to states’ rights suggests that even those who oppose racism are willing to overlook it for their own self-interest. They’re fairly unremarkable in this respect — supporting a political movement often requires making peace with ideological differences.

But it also undermines the notion that conservatism’s racism problem stems from infiltration by a few bad eggs. On the contrary, it’s been apparent since the Nixon administration that the Republican Party would collapse without support from racists. Perhaps such a demise is Douthat and Carney’s unstated goal. In any case, the GOP hasn’t been able to convince most voters that corporate welfare, reduced protections for marginalized people, and diminished health-care options for all but the most financially secure are good things on their own terms, without using racism to sweeten the deal. This wouldn’t matter if conservatism was a fringe ideology. But the writers’ portrayal of their movement as one victimized by unfair smears and mischaracterization belies its status as the most powerful political movement in America today, and that conservatives control most of the country’s most powerful political institutions.

As a result, the implementation of conservative policies means that migrant children are dying in cages, black voters are being purged from voter rolls by the thousands, Native lands are being plundered for oil infrastructure, and black mothers are losing their lives and babies because adequate health care is out of reach. It’s unlikely that many of them are moved by the gradual awakening of some conservatives to what they’ve known all along, or by Douthat and Carney’s insistence that a more benign conservatism, of which they’ve personally seen no evidence, exists. The mid-century black exodus from the GOP was no fluke or paranoid manifestation. It was a response to sustained antagonism toward their rights by Republicans. Rectifying this history will be a long and arduous task, as Carney acknowledges. But it starts with convincing everyday conservatives that it’s a worthwhile pursuit. It will mean convincing majorities of Republican-leaning voters — most of whom currently deny racism’s role in shaping society outright — that focusing on bigotry and its eradication is now a productive use of their time. But perhaps most important, it means reckoning with the fact that the movement’s racism problem is not the result of a hijacking or a coup, but of popular will. There are no innocents among today’s Republicans. There’s only the ugliness they’ve unleashed, and whether they’ve the courage to risk political ruin in order to eradicate it.

Non-racist Conservatism Would Kill the Republican Party

Promoted links by Taboola

hurricane dorian

hurricane dorian

What’s the Damage to the Bahamas After Hurricane Dorian’s Devastating Landfall?

By Matt Stieb

As rescue efforts intensify and aid pours in from abroad, 30 casualties have been reported.

The Odessa shooter didn’t get his gun from a standard private sale

Law-enforcement officials said they have identified a person of interest they suspect of illegally manufacturing and selling the rifle used in Saturday’s mass shooting in West Texas.

Authorities were in the process of investigating the Lubbock, Texas, man, whose identity they haven’t released, and were seeking to question him late Wednesday at his residence, officials said.

The U.S. Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives has been trying to piece together how Seth Aaron Ator was able to purchase the AR-15-style rifle he used to kill seven people and wound 22 before police shot and killed him.

Ator, 36 years old, was prohibited under federal law from owning a firearm because a court had previously found him mentally unfit, law-enforcement officials previously said. He had tried to buy a gun in January 2014 but failed because a nationwide criminal-background-check system flagged the mental-health determination by a local court and prevented the purchase, according to the officials.

intelligencer chats

intelligencer chats

When Will the Dems With No Chance Drop Out?

By Gabriel Debenedetti and Benjamin Hart

Intelligencer staffers discuss at what point the longshots in the primary field might call it a day.

2020 elections

How Control of the Senate Could Come Down to Two Runoff Elections in Georgia

By Ed Kilgore

Both parties are jockeying for position in Georgia with two Senate seats on the line. If no one wins a majority, huge runoff elections could follow.

The president has found someone willing to (pathetically) back him up on his Alabama obsession

While Dorian batters SC, the White House just released a statement from Rear Admiral Peter Brown defending the president’s comments on Dorian and Alabama. Brown says he briefed the president on Sept. 1 on the “possibility of tropical storm force winds in southeastern Alabama.”


marianne williamson

marianne williamson

Marianne Williamson Spars With Erica Jong Over Hurricane Prayer Tweet

By Benjamin Hart

The candidate did not take kindly to criticism over her suggestion to pray the hurricane away.


A Non-Racist Conservative Movement Would Kill the Republican Party

By Zak Cheney-Rice

Is the American right willing to risk destruction?

Following Walmart’s lead, CVS and Wegmans say you shouldn’t take guns into their stores

There’s nothing more important than the safety of our customers & employees. The sight of someone with a gun can be alarming, and we don’t want anyone to feel that way at Wegmans. For this reason, we prefer that customers not openly carry firearms into our stores.


the zucc

Facebook’s Dating Service Is, Unfortunately, Made by Facebook

By Brian Feldman

The social-media company insists its new dating service is separate from existing Facebook, but instead, it is built atop it.

2020 elections

Iowa Republican Senator Wants to Gut Social Security ‘Behind Closed Doors’

By Ed Kilgore

The salt-of-the-earth Senator Ernst is exposing her inner wing nut in treating the safety net as a “problem” elites must “solve.”

the economy

The Fastest Growing Jobs in America Don’t Require a College Degree

By Eric Levitz

Expanding access to higher education can’t revive the middle class. Only increasing the bargaining power of service-sector workers can.


New York Got to Vote for One of Five New License Plates. They’re All Awful.

By Christopher Bonanos and Thomas Alberty

The state has a history of great — even iconic — designs for plates. Why is the latest batch of choices so dismal?

the emperor’s new props

the emperor’s new props

10 Times President Trump Had the Best, Most Beautiful Props

By Margaret Hartmann

From giant stacks of blank paper to a Sharpie-altered hurricane map, no one shows off fake documents and diagrams like our commander-in-chief.


Former Campaign Staffer Drops Suit Accusing Trump of Unwanted Kiss

By Adam K. Raymond

Alva Johnson says she can’t compete with Trump’s resources, but stands by her claim.

state legislatures

state legislatures

Yet Another Prize in the High-Stakes 2020 Race: Control of Redistricting

By Ed Kilgore

Straight-ticket voting means the apocalyptic race at the top of the ballot will matter more than money or focus in state legislative contests.

the national interest

the national interest

Trump Somehow Replaces Unqualified Mideast Envoy With Even Less Qualified One

By Jonathan Chait

Out: Trump’s real-estate lawyer. In: Jared Kushner protégé. Wait, Jared has a protégé?

His campaign couldn’t spring for the train?

Beto O’Rourke spox says that he is indeed taking the Bolt bus from NY to Boston bc it pollutes less. Airport travel/security “takes nearly every bit of time as the 4 hr Bolt ride – so why not choose the lower carbon option?”



We’re All Fake Fans Now

By Will Leitch

We know more about athletes than ever, but it hasn’t made them more human to us.

So when is the Middle East peace thing actually happening?

SCOOP: Jason Greenblatt, Trump’s Mideast peace envoy, is departing his post, per multiple senior administration officials.

Replacing Greenblatt? Avi Berkowitz, a longtime Kushner aide, with Brian Hook at State Dept also expected to take on larger role.


the national interest

the national interest

Hitler Parodies Are Gone But Now Trump Has Made Them Real Life

By Jonathan Chait

The perfect meme for this era is just sitting right there.

climate change

On Climate, Sanders and Warren Must Go Nuclear

By Eric Levitz

Bernie Sanders is right that the climate crisis demands a radical break with obsolete ideologies – but that includes anti-nuclear leftism.


Trump Sharpie Memes Show the World As Trump Would Prefer It

By Adam K. Raymond

It appears the president altered a projection of Hurricane Dorian, and he’d probably like to alter these images too.

Boris Johnson’s brother can’t take Boris Johnson’s leadership anymore

It’s been an honour to represent Orpington for 9 years & to serve as a minister under three PMs. In recent weeks I’ve been torn between family loyalty and the national interest – it’s an unresolvable tension & time for others to take on my roles as MP & Minister. #overandout


hurricane dorian

hurricane dorian

Trump Insists Sharpie-Doctored Map Shows Alabama Was in Hurricane’s Path

By Matt Stieb

Even after the map, which Trump reportedly altered himself, drew widespread mockery, he reiterated his false claim about Dorian threatening Alabama.

Remember the good old days?

It used to be partisans would scour press reports for any stray detail that offered even a hint a president was less than focused on a hurricane, now the president just tweets for multiple days about Debra Messing and weather charts and golfs and that’s just kinda how it is


A useful reminder

New Marquette Law Wisconsin poll:

Biden 51%, Trump 42%

Sanders 48%, Trump 44%

Warren 45%, Trump 45%

Harris 44%, Trump 44%

September 2015:

Clinton 50% Trump 36%

Clinton 51% Bush 38%

Clinton 48% Rubio 40%



Everything We Know About Hurricane Dorian

By Chas Danner, Matt Stieb, and Adam K. Raymond

After devastating the Bahamas, the Category 3 storm is moving up the East Coast, pounding the Carolinas with heavy rain and strong winds.

Democrats look primed to do very well in state-level elections next year

Democrats were caught napping in the 2010 election ahead of the last round of redistricting — and it cost them control of Congress for nearly a decade.

Now Republicans are warning the same thing could happen to them.

Senior Republicans concede they’re at risk of losing dozens of state-level elections that will determine who wields power over the post-2020 congressional map — and potentially which party controls the chamber for the following 10 years. While Republicans are establishing a massive national infrastructure devoted to reelecting President Donald Trump and winning congressional majorities, party officials say the state legislative races are being overlooked.

Read More


Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: