Former NYPD Officer Daniel Pantaleo.
Photo: Eduardo Munoz Alvarez/AP/Shutterstock
Daniel Pantaleo, the New York City police officer who killed Eric Garner in 2014, was fired on Monday. The announcement from Commissioner James P. O’Neill resolves a crucial aspect of the fight over the 34-year-old’s fate, which drew renewed attention last month when New York mayor Bill de Blasio, a candidate for the 2020 Democratic presidential nomination, was greeted at a nationally televised debate by protesters chanting, “Fire Pantaleo!”
It’s been a costly process in all respects: The five years since Garner’s death have seen his friend Ramsey Orta, who filmed the killing and distributed the footage, harassed by police and sent to jail in what many saw as retaliation; his daughter, Erica Garner, dead of a heart attack at age 27, having become an outspoken activist for police accountability after her father’s death; and Garner’s family receiving a $5.9 million wrongful-death settlement from the city — the payment of which Ed Mullins, head of the Sergeants Benevolent Association, derided as “obscene” and “shameful” in its tacit indulgence of a man who “repeatedly chose to break the law and resist arrest.”
But until now, accountability for the perpetrator remained elusive. Pantaleo was confined to desk duty but faced no other administrative repercussions. He was still being paid upward of $100,000 annually as the police department mulled and stalled on holding disciplinary hearings and William Barr’s Justice Department announced it would not file civil-rights charges against him. Yet even as O’Neill’s decision was widely and preemptively affirmed — including by Judge Rosemarie Maldonado, who wrote after a June departmental trial that Pantaleo had lied about using an illegal chokehold on Garner — it was still a grudging one, at times veering perilously close to blaming the victim. That the commissioner spent a significant portion of Monday’s press conference suggesting that Garner might still be alive had he been in better shape and not protested his arrest conveys that, for him, the person most responsible for the 43-year-old’s violent demise is still a subject of dispute.
“It is unlikely that Mr. Garner thought he was in such poor health that a brief struggle with the police would cause his death,” O’Neill said, alluding to Garner’s weight and asthma. “He should’ve decided against resisting arrest, but a man with family lost his life, and that is an irreversible tragedy.” He added that Pantaleo has suffered as well. “[A] hardworking police officer with a family, a man that took this job to do good, to make a difference in his home community, has now lost his chosen career. And that is a different kind of tragedy.” O’Neill also framed Garner’s death as a cautionary tale — not about the dangers of hair-trigger police, but the perils of questioning their authority: “The street is never the place to argue the appropriateness of an arrest,” he said. “That is what our courts are for.”
Taken together, this framing gives the impression that blame for Garner’s death is shared between him and the man who killed him — as if being choked to death by a police officer was, at its core, a matter of one’s personal health or physical fitness. “Every time I watch that video, I say to myself, as probably all of you do, to Mr. Garner, ‘Don’t do it. Comply,’” said O’Neill. “To Officer Pantaleo: ‘Don’t do it.’” The reality is that no police officer had to approach Garner that July day in 2014, or to try arresting him for selling loose cigarettes, which he was not actually doing. And nothing about the situation required Pantaleo to wrap his forearm around Garner’s neck and clasp hands, choking him to the ground even as he waved his arms and gasped, “I can’t breathe,” 11 consecutive times.
That the precise chokehold Pantaleo used was banned by the department years ago is almost incidental, but renders the delay with which he was disciplined that much harder to excuse. Still, the narrative persists that Garner played a leading role in his own death, as articulated most bluntly by Pantaleo’s lawyers during the June departmental hearings. “[Garner] died from being morbidly obese,” Stuart London, the police union attorney leading the defense team, claimed in his opening statement, according to the Washington Post. “He was a ticking time bomb that resisted arrest. If he was put in a bear hug, it would have been the same outcome.”
There’s no evidence to suggest that this is true, and yet it’s not a surprising claim: The same ethos informs rationales for police killings of black men and boys in plenty of other cases. Whether it’s being too overweight, too asthmatic, or in cases like those of Mike Brown and Terrence Crutcher, respectively, too “demon”-like or “bad”-looking, the go-to narrative is that these victims are primarily responsible for their own deaths, a claim that serves the added function of relieving police of total culpability. This is part of the process by which officers are regularly exonerated for wrongdoing. According to CNN, citing data compiled by Bowling Green University criminal-justice professor Philip Stinson, who tracks police misconduct convictions, just 80 officers nationwide were charged with murder or manslaughter for killing someone while on duty between 2005 and 2017, and only 35 percent of those were convicted.
Pantaleo has thus far avoided criminal indictment locally, a civil-rights case federally, and still may face no criminal charges at all — a record of evasion unblemished until his firing today, and aided further by the narrative that Garner played a major role in his own killing. That O’Neill trafficked in this delusion at Monday’s press conference is not just irresponsible. It demonstrates how Garner’s death (and its fallout) was not the product of individual misconduct alone, but of a system designed to protect that individual even in the course of rebuking him.
Eric Garner Still to Blame for Own Death, Suggests NYPD Head
Promoted links by Taboola
Everybody Hates Trump’s Twitter Addiction, and It Could Become a Campaign Issue
By Ed Kilgore
Even people who don’t mind the president’s lying and racism are tired of his tweets.
It Appears Russia Is Covering Up a Nuclear Accident Again
By Matt Stieb
Reports of high radiation after a nuclear blast in the apparent quest for a “doomsday weapon” are fueling speculation of a smaller, second Chernobyl.
Jill Biden is being very direct about her husband’s appeal
NYPD Head Sends Parting Shots at Eric Garner While Firing His Killer
By Zak Cheney-Rice
“He should’ve decided against resisting arrest,” NYPD Commissioner James O’Neill said of Eric Garner.
It’s not just Russia trying to manipulate world events on the social networks
Twitter Inc. found and deleted hundreds of accounts it said China used to undermine the Hong Kong protest movement and calls for political change.
The company said it took down 936 accounts that originated within China and attempted to manipulate perspectives on the pro-democracy movement in Hong Kong. Facebook Inc., acting on a tip from Twitter, said it also found a similar Chinese government-backed operation on its social network, with five fake accounts, seven pages and three groups.
Planned Parenthood makes a very tough choice
Planned Parenthood will withdraw from Title X, the federal family planning program, rather than comply with a new Trump administration rule that restricts what health providers can say about abortion, the organization said on Monday.
The move could affect more than 1.5 million low-income women who rely on Planned Parenthood for services like birth control, pregnancy tests and screening for sexually transmitted diseases. Planned Parenthood serves about 40 percent of the four million patients under Title X. In some rural communities, Planned Parenthood is the only provider of such services.
new york city
NYPD Fires Daniel Pantaleo Over Eric Garner’s Death
By Adam K. Raymond
More than five years after Garner’s death, Pantaleo is punished for putting him in a chokehold.
Everything We Know About Jeffrey Epstein’s Death
By Chas Danner, Margaret Hartmann, and Matt Stieb
Attorney General Barr announced that he’s removed the acting Bureau of Prisons chief in the wake of Epstein’s death by suicide.
Impeachment momentum continues to grow, even with Congress in recess
How Would We Deal With Bill Clinton If Hillary Had Won?
By Ed Kilgore
On the 42nd president’s 73rd birthday, he’s probably chafing at being forgotten, but as First Gentlemen, he could have been experiencing a nightmare.
Elizabeth Warren Apologizes for ‘Mistakes’ at Native American Conference
By Adam K. Raymond
In October of last year, Warren took a widely panned DNA test to prove Native American ancestry.
NYPD fires Daniel Pantaleo
James O’Neill, NYPD commissioner, announces that Daniel Pantaleo has been fired for his actions that resulted in the death of Eric Garner.
“It’s clear,” O’Neill said that Pantaleo “can no longer” carry out the job as a New York City police officer.
the national interest
the national interest
Conservative Scholar: The Real Racists Are People Who Call Trump Racist
By Jonathan Chait
The conservative movement’s finest minds have decided Donald Trump is the victim, not the perpetrator, of racial division.
Trump Is Already Backing Away From Doing Anything About Guns
By Benjamin Hart
After a brief window during which he seemed interested in doing something serious to curb mass shootings, he has retreated to NRA talking points.
Warren apologizes to Native Americans
“Like anyone who’s been honest with themselves, I know I have made mistakes,” Elizabeth Warren tells a Native American forum in Iowa. “I am sorry for harm I have caused. I have listened, and I have learned. A lot.”
A big day for the Garner family, the NYPD, and de Blasio
New York Police Commissioner James O’Neill is holding a 12:30p press conference where it is expected he will announce his final decision regarding officer Daniel Pantaleo’s future with the NYPD, according to multiple law enforcement officials.
Trump Hired Them, Then He Called Them Incompetent
By Adam K. Raymond
Anthony Scaramucci is just the latest Trump hire to fall from the president’s good graces. So much for hiring the “best people.”
Jay Inslee, the climate candidate, is not polling well enough to make CNN’s climate debate
Nine Democratic candidates for president have qualified for next month’s Climate Crisis Town Hall, which will air exclusively on CNN platforms, and eight of them have said they will participate.
CNN is devoting the evening of Sept. 4 to the climate crisis. Eight of the Democratic candidates have accepted CNN’s invitation to discuss this critically important issue: former Vice President Joe Biden; Sen. Cory Booker of New Jersey; South Bend, Indiana, Mayor Pete Buttigieg; Sen. Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota; former Rep. Beto O’Rourke of Texas; Sen. Bernie Sanders of Vermont; Sen. Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts; and businessman Andrew Yang.
Citing a scheduling conflict, Sen. Kamala Harris of California declined CNN’s invitation.
This is almost word for word what John McCain infamously said on the eve of the Great Recession
Kellyanne Conway at the White House: “The fact is, the fundamentals of our economy are very strong”
Good scare quotes here
Anthony Scaramucci is a highly unstable “nut job” who was with other candidates in the primary who got shellaced, and then unfortunately wheedled his way into my campaign. I barely knew him until his 11 days of gross incompetence-made a fool of himself, bad on TV. Abused staff,..
The Legal Aftermath of Jeffrey Epstein’s Death: What Happens Next
By Matt Stieb
Prosecutors intend to pursue his co-conspirators, as lawyers representing his alleged victims look to dismantle his fortune.
We suspect Trump would have been far less upset if he got some of that inauguration money
Tom Barrack and Donald Trump have been friends and confidants for more than three decades — the two men are so close, for instance, that Barrack comforted Trump during the funeral of his father, Fred.
But the intimate relationship between the wealthy California investor and the president has fractured so badly that the two no longer speak, current and former White House officials say.
The key issue driving the two men apart: Barrack’s role as chairman of the president’s 2017 inauguration fund, which is under investigation by prosecutors.
Trump was “really upset” to read reports about Barrack’s role in allegedly making it easy for some foreigners and others to try to spend money to get access to Trump and his inner circle and whether some of the inauguration money was misspent, according to a senior administration official.
“The president was really surprised to read all about the inauguration and who was trying to buy access and how, because the president doesn’t get any of that money,” said the official.
A gross detail from Jeffrey Epstein’s brief time in jail
A decade ago, during a brief stint in Palm Beach County Jail, convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein made an odd purchase at the facility’s store: two pairs of small women’s panties, size 5.
It was just one of thousands of dollars of purchases made by the disgraced financier while in jail after pleading guilty in 2008 to soliciting a minor for sex, according to a purchase log. (His top purchase was single-serve cups of coffee, of which he bought more than 800 in 13 months.) But the panties raise questions about why a childless male inmate, accused of sexually abusing girls as young as 14, would be allowed to buy female undergarments so small that they wouldn’t fit an average-sized adult woman.
Sam Patten’s Wild Life As a Cooperating Witness
By Olivia Nuzzi
Mueller was listening to this guy?
Trump’s Selfish Foreign Policy Doesn’t Really Put America First
By Heather Hurlburt
Trump acts like rising tensions in Asia aren’t of interest to Americans. When a crisis comes and we don’t have the tools to respond, they will be.
The only constituent who attended Steve King’s town hall on Saturday was a 20-year-old Democrat nursing a hangover
[University of Northern Iowa student Jessica Birch] had planned on just sitting in the back of the room. When King entered, he walked back to her to greet her, then she moved herself up to a closer row as he approached the podium.
“It was very awkward, it was a very weird thing,” Birch explained. “Part of me wanted to leave, but it would be rude to leave, and the Midwestern part of me couldn’t do that. I feel bad for him a bit. But then part of me was really, really angry because other Democrats didn’t show up. I kind of let stuff he said slide, on stuff like abortion and health care, because I don’t want to get in an argument with him. I already know you’re wrong. Let’s talk about things I actually care about.” …
In telling her friends last night about her experience with King, others suggested Birch should have yelled at him.
“It’s so easy to say that, being the only person in the room is different,” Birch noted.
Once the hour-long forum was finished, King’s staff encouraged her to get a photo with the congressman.
“I politely declined, mostly because I plan to run for office and I don’t need a picture of Steve King and I shaking hands in the future,” she said.
Accused Serial Sexual Harasser Mark Halperin Signs ‘Trump’ Book Deal
By Marie Lodi
Journalists on Twitter are calling out the Democratic strategists who agreed to be interviewed by him for the book.
Biden is not winning the internet
More than 60 percent of the $13.2 million Biden has raised online came in the first week of his campaign, which launched in late April, according to a POLITICO analysis of data from the Democratic fundraising platform ActBlue. While other top candidates spiked early and then gradually raised more money online as the 2020 campaign has carried on, Biden’s pattern is similar to O’Rourke, who roared into the race with millions raised in his first day but has trickled off since then, watching his standing in the polls erode as the people who flocked to his 2018 Texas Senate campaign stop mashing the “donate” button with every email.
Unlike O’Rourke, Biden has enjoyed a steady stream of high-dollar, in-person events with big donors to bolster his finances, putting him among the top Democratic fundraisers in 2020. But the online totals are a sign that Biden has not built enthusiastic grassroots support for his presidential campaign, despite his lead in the polls.
POLITICO’s day-by-day review of presidential fundraising via ActBlue also shows that the former vice president didn’t generate other types of spikes or breakout moments that other campaigns feasted on during the first half of 2019. That includes well-received debate performances, televised town hall appearances, or even announcing support for impeaching President Donald Trump — all of which drove fundraising for other Democratic campaigns early this year.